Abu Barza reported,

I killed Abd al-Uzza bin Khatal while he was clinging to the covering of the Kaabah.

Azami 9193

Hasan

عن أبي برزة الأسلمي يقول

قتلت عبد العزى بن خطل، وهو متعلق بستر الكعبة.

الأعظمي 9193حسن

Contents

Reference

Commentary

Ayat

Collection

Jami al-Kamil

Book

Biography of the Prophet ﷺ

Chapter

Events between the expedition of Mutah and the expedition of the conquest of Makkah

Section

Those ordered to be killed on the day of the Conquest

Numbering

Jami al-Kamil 9193 (2nd edition)

Details

Collection

Jami al-Kamil

Book

Biography of the Prophet ﷺ

Chapter

Events between the expedition of Mutah and the expedition of the conquest of Makkah

Section

Those ordered to be killed on the day of the Conquest

Numbering

Jami al-Kamil 9193 (2nd edition)

Ayat

No annotations are available.

Reference

Ahmad1979419803

Nasai4072

Commentary

Zia-ur-Rahman Azami

Ahmad (19794) narrated it from Ismail, [who said], Shaddad bin Saeed narrated to me, he said, Jabir bin Amr Rasibi narrated to me, he said, I heard Abu Barza Aslami [narrate it], then he mentioned it.Ismail is Ibn Ulaya. Its chain of transmission is hasan because of Jabir bin Amr Abu Wazi Rasibi, about whom there is disagreement. Ahmad deemed him reliable, and Ibn Hibban mentioned him among the trustworthy narrators, while Ibn Main and Nasai criticized him. However, his hadith is hasan when it does not contradict [other narrations].But there is disagreement over the name of the one who killed Ibn Khatal. Waqidi held the view that it was Abu Barza Aslami, while Muhammad bin Ishaq stated definitively that Saeed bin Hurayth and Abu Barza Aslami jointly killed him. Some discussion of this has already been given in the Book of the Apostate.