Azami 3197

Abu Dawud narrated it (1917) from Hannad bin Sari and Uthman bin Abu Shayba, who both said, "Waki narrated to us, from Abdul-Majid, who said, 'Al-Adaa bin Khalid bin Hawdha narrated to me...'" Hannad said, "from Abdul-Majid Abu Amr, who said, 'Khalid bin Al-Adaa bin Hawdha narrated to me...'" and he related it.Abu Dawud said, "Ibn Ala narrated it from Waki just as Hannad said." Then he said, (1918) "Abbas bin Abdul-Azim narrated to us, Uthman bin Umar narrated to us, Abdul-Majid Abu Amr narrated to us, from Al-Adaa bin Khalid," with the same meaning.I say, and by the route of Waki, Imam Ahmad narrated it (20335), saying in it, "Al-Adaa bin Khalid bin Hawdha." It appears that the names got reversed for Hannad, so he made it "Khalid bin Al-Adaa bin Hawdha." The correct version is what Imam Ahmad and others narrated from Waki.Al-Adaa, with a fatha on its first letter and a doubled letter, embraced Islam along with his father Khalid after Hunayn. His death was delayed until after the year one hundred. As for "Khalid bin Al-Adaa bin Hawdha," Hafiz said in his biography in Taqrib (1812), "The correct version is Al-Adaa bin Khalid."Its isnad is hasan because of Abdul-Majid, who is Abdul-Majid bin Abu Yazid, Wahb Aqeeli. Ibn Main deemed him trustworthy, and Ibn Hibban mentioned him in Thiqat, and he is among the narrators of the Sunan.