Usayd bin Hudayr Ansari reported,

He was serving as governor over Yamamah, and Marwan wrote to him that Muawiya had written to him saying that if anything is stolen from a man, he has the better right to it by paying its price wherever he finds it.He said, "So I wrote back to Marwan that the Prophet ﷺ had ruled, 'If the person who purchased it from the thief is not himself under suspicion, then the owner is given a choice. If he wishes, he may take back what was stolen from him by paying its price, and if he wishes, he may pursue the thief instead.'"He added that Abu Bakr, Umar, and Uthman, may Allah the Exalted be pleased with them, all ruled in the same way.

Ahmad 17987

Sahih

حدثنا عبد الرزاق حدثنا ابن جريج قال سألت عطاء فذكر مثله قال سمعت أنه يقال خذ مالك حيث وجدته ولقد أخبرني عكرمة بن خالد أن أسيد بن حضير الأنصاري ثم أحد بني حارثة أخبره أنه كان عاملا على اليمامة فذكر معناه

أحمد 17987صحيح
Contents
Reference
Commentary
Ayat
Collection
Musnad Ahmad
Book
Usayd bin Hudayr
Numbering
Darussalam 17987
Ahmad 17987